#BeingHuman? Morning existential reflections on “Come Down From the Cross, and Then We Will Believe in You…” The people who are mocking Jesus here are, in fact, the ones who are supposed to know God best. Matthew says the chief priests were mocking Him as well (27:41), together with the crowd. Their argument sounds very reasonable from a human point of view: “He saved others; himself He cannot save. If then He is the King of Israel, let Him now come down from the cross, and we will believe Him” (27:42).
They also cite from Psalm 22:8: “He trusted in God; let Him deliver Him now if He will have Him” (27:43). But they omit the rest of the Psalm, which begins with the cry that Jesus makes a few hours later: “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (27:46). It is so easy to use the Bible as a judgment on someone else’s suffering. I experienced it between the date when Andrii was mortally wounded and the end of the funeral. I wrote about it on my blog and do not want to be repetitive…
I am not saying the Ukrainians should be viewed in Christ’s place. And I am not suggesting that anyone today is in the priests’ position… I think Matthew simply leaves a question open. Anyone who has been going through various suffering for a long time, really long time… will know what I mean: does the presence of God mean deliverance? And if there is no deliverance, is He still there?
This question predates the cross… In the wilderness, the tempter says to Jesus, “If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down” (Matt. 4:6). At Golgotha, the same “if” is being used by the religious leaders who say that if He comes down from the cross, then He must be the Son of God. But Jesus rejects that in both instances… In Gethsemane, He says that He could have asked His Father for “more than twelve legions of angels” (26:53). That is why the scoffers’ line “Himself He cannot save” is, in fact, the most accurate thing they could have said (though not in the sense they intended)… He cannot save Himself because He has chosen to remain with those for whom He came…
In this ongoing full-scale inhuman unprovoked russian war of terror (each term in this phrase matters…), many Ukrainian people are asking the same questions in the basements, bomb shelters, corridors, bathrooms (“Jesus is my Savior, bathroom is my shelter”), underground parking lots, and… at the graves. If God is in control, why do our power stations burn? If He is with us, why are the missing still missing? The list could be endless if we compiled all our “ifs…”
I believe we have the right to ask those questions from the Psalms, even though “David did not know anything about contemporary traditional Christian values…” I think what matters is the way we ask them… Especially in 2022, I noticed in my prayers about ending the russian aggression that I mixed the lament with an ultimatum to God. Now, in the fifth year of the full-scale russian war of terror, I realize that they are very different things… Lament is joining Jesus on the cross with “My God.. My God…” and the ultimatum is joining the priests and religious leaders at the cross with “If you come down, we will actually believe…” The first, for me, is the expression of my faith, not ideal, doubtful, maybe broken, but still faith… I now view the second as a faith-based contract agreement with my specific conditions… Suffering on the cross, Jesus lamented, but did not suggest the faith-based contract to His Father… Something I still try to comprehend…
The most difficult line for me is “Even the robbers who were crucified with Him, mocked Him and said the same” (27:44)… They were crucified on similar crosses like Jesus… they were under the same death sentence, and yet, being on the cross, they were still in the group with the priests at the cross… yes, one of them confessed, “a bit later…”
It is far easier to ignore the mocking of a stranger at the cross (who observes your suffering) than the mocking of a man on the very next cross (who suffers in similar ways). The mocker of the second is not easy to ignore because he is hanged beside you… A person who suffers in a similar situation has earned to be heard, even when what he says hurts… hurts deeply… And I heard it from people who have lost their houses due to russian strikes or occupation, or their beloved at the front line (sons, husbands, fathers, siblings…). And I heard it from myself in July 2024, when I got the news about the mortal wounds of my younger brother Andrii… “Our God did nothing!” Some say it out of anger, like me… Others say it because grief has left them with no other words, also like me…
In the Gospel of Luke, we read that one of the two thieves actually did change. Although it took some time… He turned to his Companion in suffering and said, “Lord, remember me when You come into Your kingdom,” and Jesus said, “Amen, I say to you today, you shall be with Me in Paradise” (Luke 23:42-43). That is all he observed really: a Man dying at his side, not putting up a struggle… I can not know which of the two will be my neighbor, but I can decide whether to take the thief’s mockery as an attack or as a cry of pain… It’s often precisely what we have felt ourselves in the middle of the existential night of the ongoing suffering…
Sovereignty of God is tricky to get right here… If it is about the idea that God simply removes suffering at my request for the faith-based contract, then the cross refutes that, and the russian inhuman war refutes it every day… If it is about the idea that God holds the world and is present with us in our existential darkness, then Matthew 27 is the full picture of that: darkness “over all the land” from the 6th hour to the 9th (27:45), and God remained in the midst of it on the cross…
It does not explain for me why this russian war, why my sibling, why this house and so on and on… During the ongoing russian war, I have learned to admit that the presence of God in our suffering is sometimes beyond me, and beyond the explanations we want to provide to those standing at a grave of the fallen…
I am also aware and observe that my theology can go wrong in two ways here. For example, if I simply say, “God is completely on our side and is going to deliver us soon,” I accept the terms of the priests’ faith-based contract, but then I have nothing to say when deliverance does not come… And it has not come since 2014… The other wrong way is that those in “religious power” (and I can find myself among them sometimes) abuse the concept of God’s sovereignty, saying, “God has His purposes; He wishes to punish or discipline you by this war or loss,” and then using that as an excuse to do nothing…
…A local church can begin by simply allowing the hard questions to be asked out loud (the bitter ones too), and leave them without answers. We practice this in our “Skelya” church… A church that can not hear mockery in its own pews will not survive, at least missionally, hearing it from the outside…
During the funeral, a local church can honor the names and the cause of the fallen, and read the Psalms of lament or even imprecatory psalms before any pastoral or theological explanations (if they needed at all). Our local church keeps the door both ways open for the neighbor who walked away from the church or God, without blaming him for a “temporary leave…” The centurion is worth remembering here too. He said, “Truly this was the Son of God!” (27:54)… but he said that only after Jesus had died… and he recognized God at the moment of His death on the cross, when Jesus was not rescued… He recognized Jesus as the Son of God in His suffering and death, not in His deliverance…
The mockers asked Jesus to come down so that they could believe, but He stayed on the cross… That was the only proof He gave to them and the other two crucified near Him… If Jesus came down from the cross, what would that have said to the family in a bomb shelter who cannot leave it because of the ongoing explosions nearby? Or to the family at a grave who lost their beloved? Or to the family who lost their house and became displaced, and many Ukrainians became displaced even two or three times?
A God who shows His power only when He saves us from suffering, through our faith-based contract with Him, has little to say to people who are still waiting for His deliverance from ongoing suffering… for almost or over 2,000 years since His crucifixion (and resurrection, yes)…
But a God who stays in the suffering is another matter… If He remained in that physical and existential darkness… on that cross… in the presence of those mockers within earshot… then on what grounds do we say that He is absent in our suffering, grief, loss, pain… in the bomb shelters, corridors, bathrooms, cemeteries… at a photo of the beloved missing on the wall in our apartment?… Perhaps the answer was given in Gethsemane, and on Via Dolorosa, and on Golgotha, and… we are not alone there and here… as we are waiting for the final answer (not the “final solution”) in the Garden of Resurrection… Taras D, Ukraine

Leave a Reply